PDA

View Full Version : South Korea's troubled export: babies for adoption


Vahz
May 26th, 2007, 11:03 AM
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070525/wl_nm/korea_adoption_dc

SEOUL (Reuters) - An Olympic hero reminds South Korea of the pain of exporting its children, while an actress expounds the joys of parenthood and the government the rewards. But South Koreans still don't like adopting other people's children.
ADVERTISEMENT

South Korea marked its home-grown adoption day earlier this month with incentives to encourage domestic adoption, telling citizens of the world's 12th largest economy its orphanages should not be filled with abandoned children.

But despite a sense of disgrace for once being one of Asia's largest providers of babies for adoption abroad, it has struggled to overcome ingrained attitudes about fostering them at home.

"Koreans have viewed adoption as something very shameful, embarrassing and fearful," said Stephen Morrison, an activist with a group called Mission to Promote Adoption in Korea.

A system of carefully kept family registries -- which normally go back several centuries -- places a premium on preserving blood lines and so discourages bringing in outsiders.

Those South Koreans who do adopt, often do so secretly. A wife might leave for the countryside, returning months later with an adopted child she says she gave birth to.

Morrison, himself a Korean adopted overseas, said attitudes have changed slightly over the past few years. Now, about a third of South Korean couples adopting children are willing to go public compared to almost none in the late 1990s.

Actress Sin Ae-la openly adopted a daughter in 2005 and the press coverage helped spur domestic adoptions in South Korea.

INCENTIVES AND ORPHANS

Olympic skier Toby Dawson is a reminder of South Korea's failure to adopt its own.

Dawson, born in South Korea and adopted by American ski instructors, became an overnight sensation in South Korea when he won a bronze medal at the Turin Olympics in 2006.

Since then, he had a tearful reunion in February 2007 with his biological father and is helping the South Korean city of Pyeonchang with its bid for the 2014
Winter Olympics.

Thousands of babies are still abandoned every year due to divorce, economic hardship and the difficulty of raising children in a society that sometimes looks on single mothers with scorn.

In a bid to spur domestic adoption, the government has pledged to cut adoption fees and subsidize medical care.

"We now have the ability to take care of abandoned children and orphans within our borders," said Kim Geum-chan, a welfare ministry official.

Since 1958, when orphans from the Korean War and the abandoned children of foreign soldiers and Korean women began to be taken in by overseas families, about 160,000 South Korean children have been adopted abroad, the welfare ministry said.

Well over half of them ended up in the United States.

In the years leading up to the 1988 Olympics when South Korea was emerging as an economic power, it sent about 8,500 children a year abroad for adoption -- a statistic which became a national embarrassment. Now, the number is a little under 2,000 a year.

At Holt Children's Services in Seoul, rosy-faced babies who will likely soon be leaving South Korea, wait in a toy-strewn room for health checks with doctors.

Holt, named after Oregon farmer Harry Holt who adopted eight Korean war orphans in the 1950s, is one of the few international adoption agencies sanctioned by the government.

"I feel so proud and happy when I see pictures of those children with their new families and they are happy and healthy," said Holt spokeswoman Kim Eun-hee.

But some child welfare advocates want to halt international adoptions, saying they leave children emotionally scarred and in search of an identity.

"It is just not right that one of the world's biggest economies is still sending its abandoned babies overseas," said Jeon Soon-geol from the Mission to Promote Adoption in Korea.

atlasien
May 26th, 2007, 11:35 AM
The cultural attitude toward domestic adoption is very similar to that in Japan. Adopting secretly is a really bad idea... adoptees should not have to feel shame or live a double life. It looks like Korea is making some great progress though. It would be great to also see a Japanese celebrity openly adopt.

More support for single mothers would also reduce children in orphanages. The problem in Japan is that so much money goes to social services for seniors, there is little regard for supporting single mothers and children.

If Korea went all-out on programs supporting single mothers and promoting domestic adoption, they could easily cut off international adoption and have no children in orphanages.


But despite a sense of disgrace for once being one of Asia's largest providers of babies for adoption abroad, it has struggled to overcome ingrained attitudes about fostering them at home.

"Koreans have viewed adoption as something very shameful, embarrassing and fearful," said Stephen Morrison, an activist with a group called Mission to Promote Adoption in Korea.

A system of carefully kept family registries -- which normally go back several centuries -- places a premium on preserving blood lines and so discourages bringing in outsiders.

Those South Koreans who do adopt, often do so secretly. A wife might leave for the countryside, returning months later with an adopted child she says she gave birth to.

Morrison, himself a Korean adopted overseas, said attitudes have changed slightly over the past few years. Now, about a third of South Korean couples adopting children are willing to go public compared to almost none in the late 1990s.

Actress Sin Ae-la openly adopted a daughter in 2005 and the press coverage helped spur domestic adoptions in South Korea.

Vahz
May 26th, 2007, 02:47 PM
I think it's not only a Japanese and Korean problem when it comes to the mentality of adoption but all of Asia. China seems to have a big problem with it as well.

The thing I find the most troubling is that Asians have to be shamed into doing something about it rather than realizing there is a problem and fixing it accordingly.

RebelAzn
May 26th, 2007, 03:39 PM
China got to let people adopt boy babies too. Right now, I believe China is the biggest place for adoptions and they are all girls. Don't they have a shortage of girls in China?

I am seriously considering adopting a kid even if I have one naturally. There is nothing wrong with it and plenty of children need homes.

I have a friend who married a girl who was adopted by a couple in the Bay Area. The couple (Chinese man married to an Irish women) adopted 8 international kids with many having disabilities. They also have 4 biological children. They managed to raise all these kids somehow. The family is just amazing.

Hater Depot
May 26th, 2007, 04:24 PM
SK has made pretty big strides in the area of adoption. I might not be remembering correctly but if I am, the ratio of domestic to international adoptions is now 1:1.

Still though, if you rank countries which send at least 50% of adoptions abroad by per capita GDP, South Korea is at the top.

If Korea went all-out on programs supporting single mothers and promoting domestic adoption, they could easily cut off international adoption and have no children in orphanages.

I once spitballed together such a campaign with some guys who work in the ministry of finance. We had some good ideas but we had nowhere to take them. It would definitely work though if done right.

Vahz
May 26th, 2007, 06:04 PM
I also about China and it's shortage of girls. If there is going to be a shortage of girls, why is China exporting them?

atlasien
May 26th, 2007, 11:15 PM
Japan, Korea and China share some cultural attitudes about adoption but their situations are all very different.

Korea = some kids in orphanages, some (growing) domestic adoption, some international adoption, very little support for single mothers. Low birthrate due to economic success.

Japan = many children in orphanages, called "childrens homes" which are well-funded still horrible places to grow up, according to all accounts I have read; almost zero international adoption and no history of international adoption, small amount of domestic adoption, little support for single mothers. Negative birthrate, shrinking and aging population.

China = huge rural/urban divide. Massive orphanage system. Many girl children given to orphanages because of one-child policy; both boys and girls often given to orphanages if born with birth defects due to one-child policy. Large amount of international adoption; growing amount of domestic adoption. Zero support for single rural mothers.

I have heard that in China nowadays, there is a trend for richer people from the cities to adopt girl children from the rural orphanages.

The shortage of girls is due to one-child policy. Many families abort girl children to make sure that their child is a boy, thus contributing to a sex imbalance. This is also a major issue in India.

kwak76
May 29th, 2007, 01:30 AM
You have to also realize that international adoption in Korea is still a business. There is cultural factor in why Korean people won't adopt but the international adoption agency makes more money when Korean kids are sent overseas.

There are adoption agency in Korea that resist against native Korean adopting Korean babies. I think to more or less degree this is also true in China and from I hear from Cambodia.

Hater Depot
May 29th, 2007, 12:42 PM
Korea = some kids in orphanages, some (growing) domestic adoption, some international adoption, very little support for single mothers. Low birthrate due to economic success.

The skyrocketing costs of housing and education are very discouraging as well.